close
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20120119215041/http://www.foreignpolicy.com:80/articles/2012/01/17/budapest_winter

Budapest Winter

Can anyone stop the Putinization of Hungary?

BY MICHAEL J. JORDAN | JANUARY 17, 2012

BERJAYA

With the European Union's threat of a lawsuit against the Hungarian government for meddling with the independence of its central bank, the world is finally taking notice of Prime Minister Viktor Orban's aggressive recent moves to consolidate power. But for some Hungarians themselves, the gravity of what's happening in today's fractious Hungarian political scene was driven home on Dec. 3 by the blurred-out face of the former Supreme Court chief justice, Zoltan Lomnici.

It was one thing for Orban's muscular center-right government to replace the upper ranks of state television and radio with its own loyalists after winning a two-thirds "supermajority" in the April 2010 parliamentary elections -- seizing control of state-run media by incoming governments still remains an acceptable spoil of political warfare in post-Communist Central and Eastern Europe.

But it was another when, in a news report, Hungarian state television pixilated the face of Lomnici -- a one-time Orban loyalist who had recent fallen afoul of the prime minister -- to conceal his identity from viewers. And that was the final straw for Hungarian TV staffers Balazs Nagy-Navarro and Aranka Szavuly.

Navarro and Szavuly say the Lomnici pixilation proved that the minions of Orban's party, Fidesz, have taken media combat one step further: They are willing to manipulate stories, edit tape to suit their agenda, and instruct reporters on whom to interview and whom to ignore.

To Szavuly, these tactics epitomize Fidesz's society-wide conquest. Step by step the party has gobbled up all forms of independence, opposition, and checks-and-balances in one of the EU's newest members -- reminiscent of the "salami tactics" of the late 1940s, when Hungarian Communists gradually hacked away at enemies like slices of salami.

Although Hungary was once "the best pupil in the class" of ex-Communist states striving to join Western institutions -- a model of economic dynamism and political reform -- wayward Budapest has become a political thorn in the side of a European Union already reeling from Euro-induced calamity.

Some Hungarians have grown so desperate at the fate of their democracy that tens of thousands regularly throng the streets in protest. It's no longer unusual to hear Hungarians make straight-faced comparisons between their country and authoritarian Belarus.

After the pixilation controversy, Navarro and Szavuly -- vice presidents of the Television and Filmmakers Independent Trade Union -- demanded an explanation.

"We wanted an investigation, but didn't get answers," says Szavuly, 32. "There was this feeling that we have no other possibility, because all the doors are closed, with nowhere to go."

So, on Dec. 10, the two journalists went on hunger strike -- later joined by two others -- planting themselves in front of Hungarian TV headquarters and subsisting for days off tea, juice, and watery soup. Navarro and Szavuly were fired on Dec. 27 and finally ended their 22-day strike on Jan. 1, unemployed. While the protest didn't have quite the impact of the Tunisian street peddler whose self-immolation sparked the Arab Spring, it clearly stirred many Hungarians.

ATTILA KISBENEDEK/AFP/Getty Images

BERJAYA SUBJECTS: EUROPE
 

Michael J. Jordan was a Budapest-based foreign correspondent for the Christian Science Monitor from 1995 to 2000. He now lives in Maseru, Lesotho. His reporting can be found at http://jordanink.wordpress.com.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit
BERJAYA

NICOLAS19

9:00 AM ET

January 18, 2012

few additions

While I'm generally as worried as the author is regarding the way things go in Hungary today, please let me post a few factual corrections here.

- Blurring. After an investigation, those responsible for the blurring have been sacked, two weeks after the incident, even before the hunger strike has begun. Hardly a sign of government puppets, right? Moreover, an official apology has been made.
Another addendum: one of the hunger-strikers, Mr. Nagy-Navarro has started his own movement and media channel since. He admittedly used the incident as a publicity stunt for his new enterprise. Given the fact that the wrongdoers have already been removed and an official apology has been issued by the time they went on strike, one questions their true motives. I agree with the author, not exactly self-immolation.

- Demonstrations. 100,000 participants were the estimate of the organizers. In reality, there were around 20-30,000 participants in the first hour, then it would shrink to 1,000-1,500 due to bad weather. I was there, and I work not far from that square, there is no way 100,000 people would fit in there. The government figures (10,000 participants) are off as well, but it is always unwise to take an interested party's word for granted.

- The far-right regiments' actions in 2009-2010 were carried out and aimed against the Roma, not the Jewish. It is equally bad, but please, stick to the facts. You should also mention that one of the first acts of the Orbán-regime was to outlaw and criminalize these groups instigating hatred, fear and intolerance towards minorities. These movements were effectively disbanded (even their uniform was banned), and their leaders are being tried right now.

- EU sanctions. I generally agree with most of the EU request regarding the financial institutions, media law and public finances. They would do this country a world of good.

However, some of the other demands are over the top. For example, they order Hungary to repeal a recent law on the retirement of judges. Before the new law, judges couldn't be forced to retire at old age, they could adjudicate cases until the grave, in the name of judicial independence. Working in the legal industry, I often have to fight an uphill battle trying to explain a 70-80 year old judge what 'hyperlink', 'firmware', or 'interactive media' is. It is insane. By objecting every single thing this government does, the EU makes it work cut out, as more and more turn against them for violating Hungary's sovereignty.

BERJAYA  REPLY
 

AARONJA

9:12 AM ET

January 18, 2012

Hungary's EU membership should be suspended

The EU should not tolerate any type of authoritarian creep amongst its member states. Allowing a country to go down this path sets a dangerous precedent. The country should be suspended from the EU and also cooperation within NATO curtailed.
Hungary can "protect its sovereignty" however it pleases, but if it is incompatible with EU principles then it can do so outside the union. EU membership is a privilege not a right. If this tiny country wants to exist as a completed isolated authoritarian island divorced from its democratic neighbours then so be it.

BERJAYA  REPLY
 

ARABAOYUNU

4:50 PM ET

January 18, 2012

you here god ride>araba park

you here god ride>araba park etme oyunlar? Navarro and Szavuly say the Lomnici pixilation proved that the minions of Orban's party, Fidesz, have taken media combat one step further: They are willing to manipulate stories, edit tape to suit their agenda,araba yar??? and instruct reporters on whom to interview and whom to ignore.

BERJAYA  REPLY
 
BERJAYA
BERJAYA