The debate over whether homosexuality is a choice (as if such a thing would be relevant to fundamental questions involving freedom) never seems to end.
Herman Cain was recently asked about choice by Joy Behar:
I mean, don’t think anybody in this world wants to be gay considering all the vilification that is brought upon someone who is gay. Why would you choose that?
I think that’s a poor way to put it. Regardless of who is born gay and who isn’t (I think both can happen, btw), does she really think that no one would ever choose lifestyles that bring on vilification?
Let’s change the phraseology a bit, by substituting a word:
I don’t think anybody in this world wants to be Republican considering all the vilification that is brought upon someone who is Republican. Why would you choose that?
Or:
I don’t think anybody in this world wants to be a Christian considering all the vilification that is brought upon someone who is Christian. Why would you choose that?
Or even:
I don’t think anybody in this world wants to be tattooed and pierced considering all the vilification that is brought upon someone who is tattooed and pierced. Why would you choose that?
I don’t know why. Because there is freedom, maybe?
My worry is that saying that people have no choice in something is a way of saying they have no freedom. The freedom to do something is just as important as the freedom not to do it.
Sometimes I think determinists want to do away with freedom.
Speaking of freedom, another question which has been vexing me is this. If a man wants to become a woman, is he free to do so, right? Or would the determinists see him as a woman who had no choice but to have been born in the body of a man, and who thus has no choice but to have sexual reassignment surgery? Really? Then why can’t a member of one race have racial reassignment procedures to become a member of another race? If I can be born into the wrong sex, then why can’t I be born into the wrong race? Why would people be born into races and sexualities, but not born into their sexes? I believe in freedom of people to be — or to try to be — whatever they want, but such inconsistencies puzzle me. I realize that a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, so maybe I am being a fool by posing such a question. If so, did I choose to be a fool? Or was I born that way?
After all, I don’t think anybody in this world wants to be a fool considering all the vilification that is brought upon someone who is foolish. Why would I choose that?












The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler







