close
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20120117213637/http://unhoused.livejournal.com/22812.html

Unhoused ([info]unhoused) wrote,
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Share  Next Entry

More interest in working on Dharavi, Mumbai

This looks interesting, though it is not clear how open it is to anyone who wants to join. Personally, I prefer the workshop being offered by Urban Typhoon (http://unhoused.livejournal.com/21602.html), which I will be attending, in the Koliwada neighborhood of Dharavi as it will be lead by people from the area and not high-profile theorists and academics from other countries. I wonder why the organizers of the Urban Body Research Studio need to maintain their academic hierarchies when going in to understand a place that could benefit from their knowledge, but in a different manner, where the people of the area are empowered and given a voice and something is built up together rather than in this top-down fashion. They say in the outline that they want to interrogate old ways of thinking about places like Dharavi, but don't seem willing to question their own inquiry and how that might get in the way of truly transformative, empowering work. I look forward to seeing what the results are of both the Urban Typhoon and Urban Body Research Studio efforts.

BERJAYA

Mapping Dharavi

Urban Body Research Studio on Mumbai

The studio aims at exploring and mapping the complexity of elements, which constitute the urban, social and cultural texture of squatter settlements in the city of Mumbai. Considering these areas within the broader framework of urban transformations and redevelopment projects, the studio looks at the slums as forms of emergent’ urbanities, which function with a multiple logic and structure of relations both within itself and with the outside.

Strategically, the studio questions both binary logics of opposition and problem-solving attitudes. Polarities such as formal/informal, legal/illegal will be put under scrutiny in order to understand the intertwining and shades of meanings that operate within a multi-faceted context. An explorative and analytical attitude will be therefore encouraged as a device to understand unfamiliar urban mechanisms in a non-judgemental way.

Questions of self-organisation, informal micro-economies, gender roles, private and public spheres will be addressed in relation to both their impact on the actual definition of the slums and to their relation to the broader network of power and political structures of the city. The main focus of the studio will be the slum of Dharavi; being the largest squatter settlement of Asia it allows for a deep and privileged understanding of the multiplicity of layers – on the local, regional and international level – that operate in the constitution and definition of these urban emergences.

Streets will be addressed as the crucial element of analysis. They represent the physical realm of interaction and social experimentation while also being the membrane through which different types of spaces mingle and transform. They will be the “laboratory” to understand relationships between flows of capital, labour forces and patterns of dwelling and inhabitation.

Throughout the nine weeks of its program, the studio will propose and interdisciplinary approach that will be developed through a variety of devices. An “action-learning” approach would foster students to embrace an experiential understanding of knowledge production.

The first four weeks will be dedicated to getting “acquainted” with the urban, social, political and cultural context of Mumbai in general and Dharavi in particular. Seminars, guest lectures, video screenings will be part of the program. Students will be also provided with a basic methodological tool-kit that will allow them to relate in a morally and professionally sober way to a non-western and unfamiliar context. The studio will then propose a three-weeks research and mapping field work in Mumbai, which will be followed by two more weeks for elaboration and post-production of the collected material.

The “results” of the studio will be presented in a public exhibition at TU Delft and NAi and will be the core material for a forthcoming publication. There will also be a follow up of the research that will be presented at the CCA, Canadian Centre for Architecture, in Montreal in the Fall of 2009.

http://www.urbanbody.org/UB2008/Mumbai/
Tags: dharavi, mumbai, workshops

Loading...
  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 2 comments
BERJAYA

Anonymous

2008-01-31 12:10 pm UTC

Urban Body: Mumbai

The Urban Body is a trans-disciplinary studio curating participatory approaches to exchange local and non-local experiences and ‘expertise’ in search for new ways of knowledge formation. The Urban Body: Mumbai engagement is not one that is ‘solving’ local ‘problems’ but is carrying out a collective research to learn from local complex conditions in order to enhance our own understanding on divergent urbanization processes. Bearing in mind the rise of a new (and gradually predominant) urban form, we are initiating this experience to kick-off a continuous inter-university research on urban emergences. Our research on Dharavi is aimed striving to elaborate not only what it is, but more on how it is constituted and how it is actualized in everyday processes; in other words investigating its highly creative cultures of production struggling for survival and growth as opposed to sympathizing with its political neglect and severe lack of services and facilities. We witness such spaces having immense vitality and are inspired to learn from their inhabitants. Simultaneously we will also be collaborating with Urban Typhoon to share and learn from each others experience. We welcome ideas and suggestion and kindly ask for them to be emailed to spacelab@bk.tudelft.nl, or they can by posted on the weblog we will be updating daily. An overview of the finalized curriculum and workshop will be uploaded this weekend. [Alexander Vollebregt - Urban Body Programme Director / TU Delft]
BERJAYA

[info]unhoused

2008-01-31 01:48 pm UTC

Thanks for the clarification

It is good to get some clarification on what the program is and encouraging that you have contacted Urban Typhoon, are aware of what they are doing, and that you are sharing information. This is great. I also understand the desire to provide a dense analysis, tools, and other means of interrogating a situation as complex as Dharavi to students. However, there are some things that seem way too familiar and impose an unspoken power structure around “beneficial knowledge production.” It looks like many other initiatives that either extract symbolic or real capital from places like Dharavi. I think that, in part, will be the result of your efforts. In fact, it echoes the book “Brakin: Brazaville – Kinshasa, Visualizing the Visible” produced by the Jan Van Eyck Acadamie. I really like the book, and how it investigates many of the same issues you are, but in a different city, but it is difficult to see how this book has use to the people its producers encountered. Your studio exceeds being just a class given that you will present your collected information in a book and a very particular exhibition form. I am curious why the studio's results won't first be presented in Dharavi and why everything is coming from and being taken too the outside. You are going there to study the creativity and the way people cope with and make a place like Dharavi vibrant. You are also creating knowledge and then taking it back to put it on display. I am curious why you can't do this there too. Why can’t it be an empowering experience for some of the actual people there? You have some of the superstars of urban planning and the discourse around global slums involved, why aren’t there activists and some of the mighty global voices that can ground the more theoretical, and abstract things that you are looking at? These are questions I think that should be asked any time a studio like yours is being done. Your studio also exceeds the university in that information about it has circulated on urban planning, urbanist, activist, and other list serves. I don’t want to give the impression that I am hostile to what you are doing. I am genuinely excited about what you are doing and will buy your book, but also have these reservations.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…