close
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20101008060613/http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/10/07/gop-senate-odds-rise-third-consecutive/

Politics



October 7, 2010, 7:36 pm

G.O.P. Senate Odds Improve for Third Consecutive Week

Democrats are on the verge of locking up several Senate races in the Northeast, including one in Connecticut that some analysts had considered a toss-up. But Republicans have gained ground overall in this week’s Senate forecast by virtue of improved polling in Nevada and West Virginia. Their odds of taking over the Senate on Nov. 2 have now improved to 24 percent — up from 22 percent last week and 15 percent three weeks ago, according to the FiveThirtyEight forecast model.

Let’s start with the good news for the Democrats, because there certainly is some of it — mostly concentrated along the Eastern Seaboard.

No fewer than five new polls have been released in Connecticut in the last week, a state where our forecasting model had long been skeptical of the chances for the Republican, Linda McMahon. Each poll shows the Democrat, state Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, with leads ranging from 7 to 13 percentage points. In addition, each of the polls also show Mr. Blumenthal with at least 52 percent of the vote, and few undecided voters remaining in the state. Under ordinary circumstances, figures like these would suggest that Mr. Blumenthal has the race all but wrapped up.

Ms. McMahon’s campaign has recently released ads critical of Mr. Blumenthal over misleading statements he made regarding his service in Vietnam, and some of the polling predates these commercials. But the polling also suggests that many voters in Connecticut feel bombarded with commercials from Ms. McMahon, who has put more than $20 million of her own money into the race, so it is doubtful the ads will be enough to allow her to overcome what is now about a 10-point deficit.

Democrats are also close to closing out the race in Delaware, with new polls showing Chris Coons with leads of 17 and 19 percentage points over his controversial opponent, Christine O’Donnell, possibly expanding what had already been a double-digit lead. Like Ms. McMahon, Ms. O’Donnell’s campaign is flush with cash, thanks to a burst of donations from conservative and Tea Party activists following her victory in the Republican primary last month. But Ms. O’Donnell’s polling deficit will be difficult to overcome and the race is perhaps best considered a curiosity rather than an integral part of the Senate picture.

Republican chances of winning the special Senate election in New York, which were never particularly strong, are also down. Their candidate there, Joseph J. DioGuiardi, whose chances improved when Carl P. Paladino made a seeming surge in the polls, may now have suffered as Mr. Paladino’s numbers have fallen back to earth. The model gives the incumbent in the race, Democrat Kirsten Gillibrand, about a 97 percent chance of winning.

These Eastern states, however — ordinarily solidly Democratic — were always something of the rainbow over the horizon for Republicans: states that might have been winnable if Democrats were to suffer losses of catastrophic proportions. But those states were not the most essential to their chances to taking over the Senate. Closer to the frontier, instead, are a set of six states — West Virginia, Nevada, Illinois, Washington, Colorado, and California — where Republican odds are notably stronger. Were Republicans to win five of the six states, they would claim control of the Senate, unless Democrats were able to engineer a rebound in a state like Wisconsin, where they now appear to be underdogs.

California is the least likely Republicans pickup; instead, the polling there has shown the Democrat, Barbara Boxer, solidifying her position in recent weeks. Still, it remains a more viable opportunity for Republicans than a state like Delaware and not one where Democrats can quite take anything for granted.

In Washington, the Democrat, Patty Murray, had also seemed to strengthen her position; several polls released last month had shown her with a lead. Since then, nonpartisan pollsters have mostly ignored the state. But the campaign of the Republican, Dino Rossi, showed itself with a 6 percentage point advantage in an internal poll it released this week.

FiveThirtyEight does not use internal polls in its Senate or gubernatorial forecasts, and they often show large divergences from nonpartisan polls — therefore, it still has Ms. Murray as the 70 percent favorite. But if public polling were to confirm that Mr. Rossi is tied or slightly ahead, that could give Republicans their clearest path to date for taking over the Senate, as they are now favored — although by slim margins — in the other four states they would need to claim the chamber.

These states include Illinois, where many voters remain undecided and the polling has stubbornly resisted moving in one or another direction, but where the model has the Republican, Mark Kirk, as a nominal, 56 percent favorite, similar to previous weeks.

These states also include Colorado. There, the polling has in fact moved slightly in the direction of the Democrat, Michael Bennet. One survey, from Public Policy Polling, in fact gives Mr. Bennet a single-point lead (Mr. Bennet’s internal polling, not used by the model, also puts him slightly ahead).  But the bulk of the evidence still suggests an advantage for the Republican, Ken Buck; the model has him as the 73 percent favorite, down from 79 percent last week.

It is in Nevada and West Virginia where Republicans have made their gains. In West Virginia, two new polls using Rasmussen Reports methodology — one released under the auspices of Fox News — give the Republican, John Raese, leads of 5 and 6 percentage points. West Virginia is in need of polling by companies other than Rasmussen — indeed, the race has yet to be surveyed by any traditional polling firm — but the model nevertheless now makes Mr. Raese a 64 percent favorite, in a reversal from last week.

Each of three polls released this week in Nevada, meanwhile, give the Republican, Sharron Angle, a small lead, ranging from 2 to 4 percentage points, over Harry Reid. Some caution is in order: two of the three polls use Rasmussen reports methodology, and some reports suggest that private polling in the state still shows Mr. Reid with an advantage. Still, Nevada had long been in a stalemate, and even if these reeds of evidence are thin, they are enough for the forecasting model to make Ms. Angle a 66 percent favorite, up from 56 percent last week.


Average outcome after 100,000 simulations

Updated Democrats Republicans Other
Senate Oct. 7 51.5 48.4 0.1
House Oct. 1 210.7 224.3 0.0
Governor Oct. 5 19.4 30.3 0.3
Senate
House
Governor
Oct. 7 Senate Forecast: Democrats lose 7.5 seats
Oct. 1 House Forecast: Democrats lose 44.3 seats
Oct. 5 Gubernatorial Forecast: Democrats lose 6.6 states
51.5
Democrats
48.4
Republicans
0.1
Other
19.4
Democrats
30.3
Republicans
0.3
Other
210.7
Democrats
224.3
Republicans
0.0
Other

Probable Senate Outcomes

76% chance that Democrats control at least 50 seats
1% chance that Democrats control at least 60 seats

Probable House Outcomes

33% chance that Democrats control at least 218 seats
BERJAYA

Probability of Party Winning Seat View Larger Map »

Senate Takeover Chances

Current Party Chance that party loses seat —— Projected Vote ——
D % R % I % Margin
N. Dakota
100% 30 68
 
Hoeven +38
Arkansas
100% 37 60
 
Boozman +23
Indiana
99% 41 56
 
Coats +15
Pa.
94% 45 52
 
Toomey +7
Wisconsin
89% 46 52
 
Johnson +6
Colorado
73% 47 50
 
Buck +3
Nevada
66% 48 50
 
Angle +2
W.Va.
64% 48 50
 
Raese +2
Illinois
56% 48 49
 
Kirk +1
Wash.
29% 50 47
 
Murray +3
Calif.
14% 51 46
 
Boxer +5
Florida
12% 23 43 33 Rubio +11
Kentucky
11% 45 52
 
Paul +7
N.H.
11% 45 52
 
Ayotte +7
Missouri
4% 44 53
 
Blunt +9
Alaska
3% 26 42 30 Miller +12
New York
3% 55 43
 
Gillibrand +12
N.C.
3% 41 56
 
Burr +14
Arizona
1% 40 57
 
McCain +17
Louisiana
1% 40 57
 
Vitter +17
Ohio
1% 43 55
 
Portman +12
Maryland
1% 58 39
 
Mikulski +19
Delaware
1% 55 42
 
Coons +13
Oregon
1% 57 41
 
Wyden +16
Conn.
0% 55 43
 
Blumenthal +11
Georgia
0% 38 59
 
Isakson +21
Iowa
0% 37 60
 
Grassley +22
Utah
0% 36 61
 
Lee +24
Vermont
0% 61 36
 
Leahy +26
New York
0% 60 38
 
Schumer +22
S.C.
0% 32 65
 
DeMint +34
Oklahoma
0% 29 69
 
Coburn +40
Kansas
0% 31 66
 
Moran +35
Alabama
0% 33 64
 
Shelby +31
S. Dakota
0%
 
100
 
Thune +100
Idaho
0% 29 68
 
Crapo +39
Hawaii
0% 65 33
 
Inouye +32

House Takeover Chances

Likely Takeover

Current party has greater than 80% chance of losing seat
 
98% NY-29
 
89% LA-3
 
83% MD-1
 
98% AR-2
 
88% DE-1
 
82% WA-3
 
97% TN-6
 
88% MI-1
 
82% IL-11
 
96% VA-5
 
85% NH-1
 
81% PA-10
 
95% TX-17
 
85% AR-1
 
81% PA-11
 
93% IN-8
 
84% TN-8
 
80% CO-4
 
92% KS-3
 
83% MS-1
 
80% ND-1

Lean Takeover

Current party has between 60 and 80% chance of losing seat
 
80% OH-16
 
74% WI-8
 
67% LA-2
 
79% OH-1
 
74% PA-3
 
65% AL-2
 
78% WI-7
 
73% NY-19
 
64% NH-2
 
78% MI-7
 
73% OH-15
 
64% GA-8
 
76% PA-7
 
72% AZ-1
 
62% NY-24
 
76% FL-24
 
71% PA-8
 
61% FL-8
 
76% AZ-5
 
71% VA-2
 
 
74% NM-2
 
70% SD-1
 

Even Chance of Takeover

Current party has between 40 and 60% chance of losing seat
 
59% HI-1
 
53% PA-12
 
43% IL-17
 
57% IN-9
 
52% SC-5
 
42% NC-7
 
56% WV-1
 
51% IL-14
 
42% NC-8
 
56% CO-3
 
50% IA-3
 
41% AZ-8
 
56% TN-4
 
48% NV-3
 
41% TX-23
 
55% CA-11
 
47% FL-22
 
 
54% IL-10
 
46% MO-4
 

Takeover Possible

Current party has between 20 and 40% chance of losing seat
 
38% MS-4
 
29% NC-11
 
23% WV-3
 
36% OH-18
 
29% WA-2
 
21% CO-7
 
35% KY-6
 
29% NJ-3
 
21% NY-13
 
35% FL-2
 
28% OR-5
 
20% NY-23
 
35% ID-1
 
25% OH-6
 
 
34% MI-9
 
24% MA-10
 

Gubernatorial Takeover Chances

Current Party Chance that party loses seat —— Projected Vote ——
D % R % I % Margin
Florida *
100% 48 49
 
Scott +1
Wyoming
100% 37 61
 
Mead +24
Kansas
100% 38 61
 
Brownback +23
Oklahoma
100% 39 59
 
Fallin +20
Iowa
99% 41 56
 
Branstad +16
Tennessee
98% 41 56
 
Haslam +15
Michigan
96% 43 54
 
Snyder +12
Pa.
95% 44 54
 
Corbett +9
R.I.
91% 37 28 32 Caprio +5
Hawaii
91% 55 44
 
Abercrombie +11
Wisconsin
87% 46 53
 
Walker +6
Ohio
86% 46 51
 
Kasich +6
N.M.
85% 46 52
 
Martinez +6
Maine
82% 39 46 11 LePage +7
Conn.
82% 52 46
 
Malloy +5
Illinois
79% 45 49
 
Brady +4
Vermont
78% 52 46
 
Shumlin +6
Minnesota
77% 45 40 13 Dayton +5
Calif.
75% 51 47
 
Brown +3
Oregon
58% 49 50
 
Dudley +1
Mass.
25% 46 42 9 Patrick +4
Georgia
21% 46 51
 
Deal +5
Maryland
11% 52 45
 
O'Malley +8
Texas
10% 44 52
 
Perry +8
S.C.
7% 44 53
 
Haley +10
N.H.
7% 53 44
 
Lynch +9
Arkansas
3% 55 42
 
Beebe +13
Colorado
3% 47 22 29 Hickenlooper +18
Arizona
2% 41 57
 
Brewer +15
S. Dakota
1% 41 57
 
Daugaard +16
Alabama
1% 41 57
 
Bentley +17
New York
1% 57 42
 
Cuomo +15
Nevada
1% 41 57
 
Sandoval +16
Alaska
1% 40 57
 
Parnell +17
Idaho
0% 38 57
 
Otter +19
Nebraska
0% 35 62
 
Heineman +28
Utah
0% 35 62
 
Herbert +27
* Charlie Crist was elected as a Republican but changed to no party affiliation in May.

About the Blog

FiveThirtyEight’s mission is to help New York Times readers cut through the clutter of this data-rich world. The blog is devoted to rigorous analysis of politics, polling, public affairs, sports, science and culture, largely through statistical means. In addition, FiveThirtyEight provides forecasts of upcoming presidential, Congressional, and gubernatorial elections through the use of its proprietary prediction models. Read more »

Recent Posts

October 07

G.O.P. Senate Odds Improve for Third Consecutive Week

More bright spots for Republicans Senate candidates as they head toward midterm elections.

October 07

Illinois Voters, Unhappy With Candidates, Show Few Signs of Committing

We haven't written as much about Illinois as some other Senate contests -- but it may be taking on an increasingly important role as some other races that had once looked to be competitive, like Connecticut and Missouri, now show a clearer advantage for one or another party.

October 06

Shifting Tides in Governors’ Races: Brown Now 3-to-1 Favorite

Jerry Brown now looks to have a 75 percent chance of defeating Meg Whitman in California, while new polls move the needle in Illinois, New Mexico, Maryland and several other states.

October 06

Understanding and Misunderstanding the ‘Enthusiasm Gap’

When you hear the phrase "enthusiasm gap," what you should really be thinking of is the turnout gap.

October 05

‘Likely Voter’ Gap Favors G.O.P. by 6 Points; Gallup’s Model Sees It Bigger

If they hold up, Gallup's numbers would mean a nightmare for Democrats.