close
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20100724231531/http://www.computing.co.uk:80/computing/comment/2258762/dangers-delights-web
Tom Young

The dangers and delights of the web

The anonymity that the internet affords can foster lively and robust debate – but it also brings dangers

Written by Tom Young

The anonymity of the web gives people the cover to get away with such language without being hit in the face

 

Having spent many a column espousing the wonders of the internet, my final column will sound a warning on the dangers.

The first is anonymity. This can be a curse and a blessing online. Sites such as Wikileaks – which desperately needs funding to stay open – provide a valuable place where information can be put into the public domain anonymously.

But there is a flip side. Glance at the comments below any newspaper opinion article and you will be given a whirlwind tour of the most unpleasant aspects of the public psyche.

You don’t overhear conversations such as this in the pub or at work. It’s the anonymity that provides people with the cover to get away with such language without being hit in the face.

And it’s the anonymity the internet provides that allows authoritarian regimes to spy on businesses without the state being held responsible.

It allows criminals to perpetrate scams online that cost the public billions of pounds a year, and illegal downloaders to ply their craft without fear of apprehension.

One of the original, long-abandoned arguments for ID cards was that they could provide a person with a secure online identity, so when you logged on to your bank’s web site, for example, you could prove your identity. If people were more accountable for their online interactions, they might be more civil – and law abiding.

But the internet carries an arguably more pervasive and long-term danger than the provision of anonymity and that is the way that it changes and shapes thinking and the way people interact with information.

The online forum edge.org recently tackled this problem. It asked leading scientists, technologists and thinkers: How is the internet changing the way you think? A number of people, including American writer Nicholas Carr and science historian George Dyson, outlined fears that the web is at risk of reducing serious thought rather than promoting it.

One argument posits that a more democratic approach – with everything posted online attributed an equal weight, whether right or wrong – encourages a cavalier attitude to the truth.

Another is that collecting information online reduces our attention span. We will scan a Wikipedia article on a subject, rather than read a book about it.

Furthermore, it is harder to distinguish between the relative value of sources online. Whereas in real life we would trust a professor more than a eight-year-old, online those boundaries are blurred by a lack of clear distinction between sources – both people would be able to type a comment on a site, and we have no way of knowing who they are, other than their words.

The “trust distinguishers” we use in the physical world are easier to fake online. Whereas a professor offline could be examined for reliability by his age, manner of speaking and so on, these things are easier to disguise on the web.

In many ways the internet represents many of the same problems as a democracy. By giving an equal voice to all, it empowers many of those who are disenfranchised economically or socially and who would not otherwise be heard.

But at the same time, it gives an equal voice to the extremities of society – making it easier for those who run extremist jihadi sites, or sites that deny the holocaust, to spread information.

Just as in real life, nobody should be denied freedom of speech online. The internet can and must be accessible to everyone. But we need to develop and teach new ways in which to distinguish between, and prioritise, information that we find online if we are to retain our notions of what is correct and incorrect.

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

 

related white papers

today's top stories

UK financial services firms set to miss FCSC legal requirement

Poor data quality means that banks are unlikely to be ready to comply with new single customer view regulation, according to a survey 23 Jul 2010

E-Borders IT supplier Raytheon Systems gets the boot

Government states that it has been in breach of contract since July 2009 22 Jul 2010

Q&A: MySpace chief data architect Don Watters

Can MySpace beat Facebook in social networking battle? 21 Jul 2010

Windows 7 migration costs laid bare

Martin Courtney investigates if spending £1,360 per PC migrating from Windows XP to Windows 7 is worth the effort – and how do you keep IT labour costs down? 20 Jul 2010

Building a valid Digital Economy

BT and TalkTalk are trying to repeal the Digital Economy Act, the House of Lords has requested the power to review the legislation and Ofcom still doesn’t know exactly how to make it work 16 Jul 2010

Advertisement

BERJAYA

How to achieve business and financial-system implementation success
A look at how organisations - regardless of size - can work towards successful business software installations and factors that determine the outcome.

BERJAYA

Case study: Specsavers put customer care into focus
How Specsavers captured customer feedback at point of sale and incorporated the results into its CRM system.

Advertisement

BERJAYA

BERJAYA

Citrix

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you thousands of white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

ICO to lean more heavily on public sector bodies

ICO to lean more heavily on public sector bodies

The ICO has said it will lean more heavily on public sector bodies to secure timely FOI responses, do you think this is:

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

picture of Jason HartVideo

Ethical hacker reveals the security secrets behind cloud computing

Jason Hart, Senior VP at Cryptocard, shows Computing just how easy it is to illegally gain access to corporate cloud services to wreak havoc and steal money. 29 Jun 2010

gartner logoVideo

Part 1: 2010 trends in SOA and Application Development and Integration

Gartner analyst Paolo Malinverno explores trends in SOA 29 Jun 2010

Latest in-depth articles

Generated image of people meeting and talkingAnalysis

JC Decaux chooses open source BI system over Oracle's

UK-wide rollout to take place over three years 23 Jul 2010

Quocirca blogComment

Six reasons why encryption vendors have a future – for now

Bob Tarzey, analyst and director at Quocirca blogs on the future of encryption 23 Jul 2010

Primary Navigation