Size really does matter…for ETFs
- Posted by: abnormalreturns, October 9th, 2009 at 2:36 pm
- Comments: 0
We are no strangers to the world of ETFs, but the following observation took us by surprise. A single fund, the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index Fund (EEM) generates some $240 million in revenue per annum for its sponsor. Ian Salisbury at WSJ goes on to note how lower trading costs have kept EEM on top against its much thriftier competitor the Vanguard Emerging Markets Stock ETF (VWO). In short, size matters in the ETF industry. And by industry, we mean industry.
There certainly are benefits to size in the ETF world, but there is a downside as well. Funds that were originally thought to be niche products have in some cases have seen explosive growth. This growth has put pressure on their ability to produce the returns they set out to generate. Therefore owning an ETF that invests in gold, commodities, or junk bonds is not the same thing as holding the underlying asset(s).
In some of these cases the ETF industry has tried to take something that is complex and make it seem simple. Unfortunately something can get lost in the translation. In addition the issuance of an ETF can change the dynamics of a market, something not always contemplated prior to a fund launch.
That is not to say that being too small in world of ETFs is not a problem as well. We have written about the risks of so-called orphan or “zombie ETFs” that are too small and illiquid. One need not look far to see that a broad swath of the ETF industry is potentially on the chopping block.
The ETF genie is out of the bottle. Once traders and investors have gotten a taste for the convenience of an ETF it is unlikely that they will go back to the staid world of open-end funds or other alternatives. For example when the United States Natural Gas Fund (UNG) ran into issues with position limits and share issuance you did not hear about a rush to open futures accounts so as to hold natural gas futures.
In short, the beast must be fed. That being the case, the challenge is finding ETFs that will perform as advertised. As Izabella Kaminska at FT Alphaville writes:
The biggest problem facing ETF investors now, according to the asset manager, is being able to discern the good funds from the bad — which ETFs have given into temptations to add revenues by lending assets out or buying derivatives instead of assets and which have not. In short, discerning which funds own what they say they own.
David Merkel at the Aleph Blog has a nice post up that discusses the many risks which help identify a “bad ETF.” These risks include: credit risk, roll risk, market size risk, replication risk, and faddishness. Maybe more importantly he also highlights the characteristics of a “good ETF”:
-Small compared to the pool that they fish in;
-Follow broad themes;
-Do not rely on irreplicable assets;
-Storable, they do not require a “roll” or some replication strategy;
-Not affected by unexpected credit events;
-Liquid in terms of what they represent, and liquid it what they hold.
In short, one could characterize the funds that fit these criteria as being real funds. That is they are designed to perform up to the expectations of the fund’s benchmark. There are a number of ETFs like that out there. However some people have given up on that search.
For example, Howard Lindzon wrote upon hearing the news that Blackrock (BLK) was purchasing the iShares ETF business from Barclays (BCS) wrote:
I was once a fan of ETFs, but the top is long in on these financial marketing schemes sold on the basis of diversification and cost savings.
ETFs will continue to work for those that create them and market them smartly as well as the few that know how to trade them. I don’t fit into any of these categories.
Caveat emptor. ETFs can be a wonderful tool for investors, but ETFs are also a business. A big business. If you want to continue playing in the ETF sandbox make sure you know the distinction between a good ETF and a bad ETF. Because the ETF sponsors are not going to tell you which is which.
Subscribe to our RSS FeedThe Latest
-
Friday links: money moves
abnormalreturns, October 9th, 2009 at 11:46 am, Comments: 0Phibro (and Andrew Hall) go to Occidental Petroleum (OXY) at a seeming bargain. (Clusterstock, 24/7 Wall St., WSJ, DealBook, Felix Salmon)
Jim Simons is retiring from his hedge fund firm. (DealBook, WSJ, Zero Hedge )
As Zoe Cruz jumps into the hedge fund game. (WSJ, DealBook)
David Rosenberg vs. Eddy Elfeinbein on market valuations. (The Money Game, Crossing [...]
-
Fourth blogiversary
abnormalreturns, October 9th, 2009 at 8:01 am, Comments: 0Not sure what is bigger news this morning. The fourth blogiversary* of the Abnormal Returns blog or Barack Obama winning the Nobel Peace Prize. Let’s go with the whole blogiversary thing.
A great deal has happened since our last blogiversary: the global financial system nearly collapsed, the Chicago Cubs once again failed to win the World [...]
-
A false dichotomy
abnormalreturns, October 8th, 2009 at 2:25 pm, Comments: 0With the popularity of active asset allocation programs, read market timing, on the rise we noted some analysts who were noting that a good old fashioned buy and hold strategy might be the best way to approach the next few years.
Indeed the performance of the market this year might very well reinforce the notion that [...]
-
Market valuation backdrop revisited
abnormalreturns, October 8th, 2009 at 12:47 pm, Comments: 0A few weeks ago we discussed using market valuation measures as a backdrop for making investment decisions. At the time our general conclusion was that the market had moved from significant undervaluation to being roughly fairly valued and that the so-called easy money had been made.
Another indicator, the ratio of equity market capitalization to GDP [...]
-
Thursday links: trending and thinking
abnormalreturns, October 8th, 2009 at 11:17 am, Comments: 0“The market is just trending. When it’s trending you can’t think.” (Howard Lindzon)
“(A)nalysts are more bullish heading into the current earnings season than they have been at the start of any other earnings season since the recession began.” (Bespoke)
September was another good month for hedge fund returns. (DealBook, WSJ)
The collapse of Lehman led to a [...]
-
Wednesday links: trade opportunities
abnormalreturns, October 7th, 2009 at 11:15 am, Comments: 0“Much of options trading involves an ability the look at a trading screen itself and simply develop a sense of whether there’s a trade opportunity or not.” (Daily Options Report, ibid)
Have we established a new range for the VIX? (VIX and More)
The weaker dollar illustrated via currency ETF performance YTD. (Bespoke)
“Unfortunately hope is a money-loser [...]
-
Tuesday links: sidelined cash
abnormalreturns, October 6th, 2009 at 11:36 am, Comments: 0The now famous “four bears” chart sure looks different today. (dshort)
The “money on the sidelines” argument is a canard. (MarketBeat also FT Alphaville)
Sometimes the stock market doesn’t care what is happening in the real economy. (Big Picture)
Was last year’s market crisis a “once in a lifetime” sort of event? (SSRN)
After a decade of poor stock [...]
-
Buy and hold comeback?
abnormalreturns, October 5th, 2009 at 1:46 pm, Comments: 0We having been writing a fair amount on the topic of asset allocation of late. In our Sunday linkfest we noted two pieces on asset allocation (Aleph Blog & Barron’s) that discuss the benefits of assessing investment risk in a multi-dimensional way. One conclusion from this sort of approach is a more active approach to [...]
Tickers: Buy and hold, Market timing
-
Monday links: profit margin rebound
abnormalreturns, October 5th, 2009 at 11:40 am, Comments: 0Two positive short term signals for the stock market. (Small Fish, Big Odds, Quantifiable Edges)
Parsing signals from the Nasdaq TRIN. (VIX and More)
“If instead you blame Goldman for every loser trade, you’ll truly never win in this biz.” (Daily Options Report)
Is buy-and-hold poised for a comeback? (Curious Capitalist)
The stock market anticipating a rapid rebound in [...]
-
Tadas Viskanta is the founder and sole editor of Abnormal Returns, one of the most popular and widely praised finance blogs. Since its inception... More »
-
-
Loading...
-
Archives
- Technical Analysis
